Kāinga Akademia Whakataurua Uniswap vs Balancer: Whakatauritea DEX
DEX

Uniswap vs Balancer: He mea pai ake?

Whakatauritea a Uniswap me Balancer ngā whakawhiti kore-ā-roto. Arotakea ngā rerekētanga i ngā tauira AMM, ngā momo pūkau wai, ngā hanganga utu, te whakahaere, me te tautoko aho.

I whakahoutia 2026-03-08 Whakatauranga DEX
UN
Uniswap (UNI)
-- --
BA
Balancer (BAL)
-- --

Uniswap ki Balancer i te Tirohanga

Āhuatanga
UNI
BAL
Tauira AMM
Hua pūmau (v2), waiwai kōwhiri (v3)
Ngā pūkete taumaha me ngā ōwehenga tohu ka taea te whakarite
Momo Pūkete
Ngā pūkete tokoro e rua (v2 me v3)
Pūkete taumaha, pūkete pūmau, pūkete whakapiki, pūkete whakahaere, me ngā pūkete rārangi
Mōra Tōken i te Pūkete
2 tōken i te pūkete
Kia tae ki 8 tōken i te pūkete
Hanganga Utu
Ngā taumata utu pūmau (0.01%, 0.05%, 0.3%, 1%)
Ngā utu ka taea te whakarite e ngā kaihanga pūreke
Māwai i whakakotahitia
Āe (v3) — Ka tautuhi ngā LP i ngā awheawhe utu
Kāore i roto i ngā pūreke paerewa; ka whakamahi i ngā pūreke whakapiki mō te whaihua
Tōken Whakahaere
UNI — kāwanatanga i runga i ngā tawhā o te kawenata
BAL — kāwanatanga me te veBAL mō te ine i ngā utu
Whakaputanga maha-aho
Ethereum, Arbitrum, Optimism, Polygon, Base, BNB Chain, me ētahi atu
Ethereum, Arbitrum, Optimism, Polygon, Avalanche, Gnosis, me ētahi atu
Rahi Hokohoko
DEX nui rawa i runga i te rahi hokohoko
Rahi nui engari iti iho i te Uniswap
Ngā whakatenatena LP
Utu hokohoko anake (kāore he tuku UNI ki ngā LP)
Tuku BAL i ārahi e te pōti piro veBAL
Aratohu Ota Matauranga
Uniswap Auto Router mō ngā ara tino pai
Balancer SOR ka kohikohi puta noa i ngā momo pūreke
Tauhokohoko Motuhake

He aha te Uniswap?

Ko Uniswap te whakawhitiwhiti kore rangatū nui rawa atu i te rahi hokohoko, e tūārahi ana i te tauira AMM hua pūmau. I whakaurua e Uniswap v3 te liki pūkete arotahi, e āhei ana ngā LP ki te tohatoha pūtea i roto i ngā tawhiti utu motuhake mō te whaihua nui ake.

Tika: UNI Mai i te tau 2018
Tauhokohoko Motuhake

He aha te Balancer?

Ko Balancer he whakawhiti kāore i te rangatū me te kaiwhakahaere pūkete aunoa e tautoko ana i ngā pūreke taumaha me te nui rawa atu o ngā tohu 8 i ngā ōritanga ka taea te whakarite. Ka taea e ia te whakaaetanga o ngā momo pūreke uaua tae atu ki ngā pūreke whakapiki, ngā pūreke pūmau, me ngā pūreke whakahaere.

Tika: BAL Mai i te 2020
Pānuihia te tuhinga katoa

Ngā Rerekētanga Matua

Kei ngā pūreke Uniswap he 2 tohu tonu, ā, ko Balancer e tautoko ana i ngā pūreke taumaha me te nui rawa atu o ngā tohu 8 i tētahi ōritanga ritenga, e whakaaetanga ana i ngā hua pēnei i te pūtea tohu.

Uniswap v3 i tūāhua i te waiwai kōwhiri e āhei ai ngā LP ki te arotahi i te pūtea ki ngā tawhiti utu motuhake, ā, ko Balancer e whakamahi ana i ngā pūreke pūmau kua whakapakari, ka taea te whakakotahi, mō te whaihua pūtea.

Balancer e whakamahi ana i tētahi tauira tokenomics veBAL, e pōti ana ngā kaipupiri BAL kua mau i ngā taumaha o te rautaki waiwai mining, ā, kāore a Uniswap e tuku i ngā tohu UNI ki ngā kaiwhakarato waiwai.

Uniswap he rārangi utu mau (0.01%,0.05%,0.3%,1%), ā, ka whakaaetia e Balancer ngā kaihanga pūreke ki te tautuhi utu whakawhiti ritenga.

Ko Uniswap te rangatira i te rahi hokohoko DEX, ā, kei a ia te waiwai hohonu rawa mō te nuinga o ngā tātau tohu, ā, ka noho hei kōwhiringa taunoa mō ngā whakawhiti tohu māmā.

Ka mahi a Balancer hei DEX me te kaiwhakahaere pūkete aunoa, e āhei ana i ngā kaiwhakamahi ki te waihanga pūkete taumaha e whakahou anō i a rātou.

Kei tēhea e tika ana mōu ki te kōwhiri?

Ko Uniswap te DEX rangatira mō te whakawhiti token māmā me te mokowā hohonu rawa atu me te rahi nui rawa. Ka tino pai a Balancer i ngā whirihoranga pūrewa ritenga, pūrewa maha‑token, me ngā rautaki mokowā ka taea te whakatakoto. Mō te nuinga o ngā kaihokohoko, ka tuku a Uniswap i te whakatinanatanga pai rawa, ā, ko Balancer he pai ake mō te whakarato mokowā matatau me te whakahaere pūkete.

Ngā Pātai Auau

He aha te mokowā arotahi i Uniswap v3?
Ka taea e te moana moni whakatōpū ngā LP ki te tohatoha pūtea i roto i te awhe utu motuhake, kaua i te awhe katoa 0 ki te mutunga kore. Ka whakapai ake tēnei i te whaihua o te pūtea, nā te mea ka whiwhi utu anake ina noho te utu i roto i te awhe kua kōwhiria e te LP's.
He aha ngā pūreke taumaha a Balancer?
Ka taea e ngā pūreke taumaha te whakauru i te 8 tohu i roto i tētahi pūreke kotahi me ngā ōritanga taumaha ritenga (hei tauira, 80/20, 60/20/20). Ka whakahou aunoa te pūreke i ngā ōritanga nei, e mahi ana pēnei i tētahi pūtea tohu e whiwhi ana i ngā utu tauhokohoko.
He DEX e whai utu iti ake mō ngā kaihokohoko?
Ka tuku ngā mea e rua i ngā utu whakataetae. He pūkete a Uniswap v3 me ngā utu iti rawa 0.01% mō ngā tātua pūmau. Ka tautuhi ngā kaihanga pūkete Balancer i ngā utu ritenga. Ka whakawhirinaki te utu tūturu ki te pūkete motuhake, te tātua tohu, me ngā utu huka i te whatunga kua tīpakohia.
He aha te veBAL?
ko te veBAL he BAL i whakatūria mā te pōti, ka whiwhi mā te kākā BAL/ETH 80/20 LP mō te roanga o te tau kotahi. Ka pōti ngā kaipupuri veBAL mō te tikanga o te tohatoha o ngā utu rahi waiwai BAL ki ngā pūreke, ā, ka whiwhi wāhanga o ngā utu tukanga.
Ka taea e au te whakamahi i Uniswap me Balancer i runga i te Layer 2?
Āe. Ka whakatūria ngā tikanga e rua i runga i ngā whatunga Layer 2 maha, tae atu ki Arbitrum me Optimism, e iti ake ana ngā utu hinu i te Ethereum mainnet, engari ka mau tonu ngā tiaki haumaru.

Tīmata Whiwhi i tō Crypto

Whiwhi tae atu ki te 7% APY i ngā moni pūmau mā Coinstancy. Kāore he here, ka taea te tango i ngā wā katoa.

Tīmata te whiwhi